| Platinum | Eclipse Pizza Company |
| Gold | Nu Yalk Pizza |
| Silver | Pizza Baron |
| Silver | R-Town Pizza |
| Bronze | Longboards Beach Fired Pizza |
| Bronze | Mofos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bully's Sports Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Mod Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pub N Sub |
| Top Pick | Southcreek Pizza Company |