| Platinum | R-Town Pizza |
| Gold | Noble Pie Parlor Midtown |
| Silver | Pizza Plus |
| Bronze | The Blind Onion Pizza & Pub So. Virginia |
| Top Pick | Boulevard Pizza |
| Top Pick | J J's Pie Co |
| Top Pick | Mofos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Factory |
| Top Pick | Rick's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Wild Garlic |